Challenger Terie Diat defeated incumbent Chris Fiore for a one-year term on the North Haven Village Board on Tuesday.
Ms. Diat received 148 votes to Mr. Fiore’s 120.
Mr. Fiore was appointed in April to fill the seat of the late Trustee James Davis, who died in February, and was required to run this year to complete the final year of the term.
The race was a rare contested election in the quiet village.
Incumbent Mayor Jeff Sander and Trustees Dianne Skilbred and David Saskas, who ran unopposed, were all reelected.
Mr. Sander received 200 votes, while Ms. Diat received one write-in vote for mayor.
In the trustee races, Ms. Skilbred received 196 votes and Mr. Saskas received 189. Larry Baum received two write-in votes, and Claas Abraham received one write-in vote.
Sag Harbor Results
Voting was subdued in Sag Harbor, where incumbent Trustees Tom Gardella and James Larocca ran unopposed.
Mr. Gardella received 56 votes, while Mr. Larocca received 47 votes. Write-ins were cast for Mary Anne Miller, Joe Labrozzi Sr., and Donald Trump.